Paul wrote a letter to a man whose slave had run away, and when finished, he handed it to that slave to deliver. To the slave’s master. Thirteen hundred miles away.
The slave’s name—Onesimus— means “useful.” It’s exactly the kind of name a master gives a slave — the way you’d name a tool. At least it beats some alternatives. Paul’s scribe mentioned in Romans went by Tertius—“Number Three.” Paul doesn’t say that Tertius was a slave, but slaves often received names like that.
A runaway slave is literally “useless,” but that’s not the worst of it. His escape tells all the other slaves their servitude isn’t inevitable, that they, too might be free. The existence of successful runaways threatened the institution of slavery. And a collapse of slavery posed a threat to the Empire itself.
To make things worse, a runaway may have taken something on the way out. Slaves had access to nearly everything in their master’s household. They knew the location of jewels and other valuables. The runaway slave himself possessed significant monetary value, and if he took some other treasure as he left, the master could face hardship and even financial ruin.
Paul knows all this, and he can’t resist the pun:
“Formerly he was useless to you, but now he is indeed useful to you and to me.” (Philemon 11)
Useful, useless, useful. First the name served as a label, then an ironic contradiction. Now it’s a tribute. Something happened to Onesimus in Rome. Paul calls him “my child, whom I fathered in my imprisonment” (v. 10). The runaway met Christ in a prison cell, of all places, and became the man his name had always claimed he was.
Paul would like to keep him. He says so. Onesimus has been serving him faithfully, and an old man in chains doesn’t easily give up a son. But Paul won’t do it without Philemon’s consent. Onesimus belongs, by law, to someone else.
So Paul sends him back.
Think about what that means. The Roman Empire had no mail service. The Emperor and powerful officials had couriers, as well as wealthy Romans. Prisoners like Paul did not. He had to rely on friends and supporters. He could not mail the letter to Philemon. Someone had to carry it. Carry it 1300 miles.
The letter needed to reach Philemon’s hands. Onesimus needed to face the man he had wronged. Both the parchment and the runaway had to make the journey down the Lycus Valley. Sending the letter by someone else would only complicate an already delicate situation. The facts suggested a simple resolution: Onesimus should carry the letter—and himself—back to Philemon.
At the same time, Paul had a second, broader letter addressed to the entire Colossian congregation. He could not hand that scroll to Onesimus. In the first century, the carrier of an apostolic letter acted as the sender’s official representative. Putting the church’s letter in a runaway slave’s hands would have elevated Onesimus over his own master.
So Paul gave the second letter, for the whole congregation, to Tychicus. Onesimus carried the letter to Philemon. Two letters, two carriers, one house, and Paul kept them separate. The church would hear its letter. Philemon would face his slave. Did you see the irony? A man who used to run now walks toward judgment carrying a letter. And the letter, as we’ll see next time, contains a promise from Paul that makes it much more than a plea for mercy.
It was a legal document. And Paul signed it with his own hand.